There is something wonderfully comforting about stepping into a fantasy dungeon with a party of adventurers, a collection of questionable equipment and absolutely no idea what might be waiting around the next corner. For those who grew up with classic dungeon crawlers such as Dungeon Master, Eye of the Beholder and Lands of Lore, that feeling is difficult to replace. Underkeep understands exactly why those games remain so fondly remembered, and rather than simply copying their appearance, it attempts to capture the spirit of that era while making the experience considerably more welcoming for modern players. Developed by Czech indie studio Rake in Grass, this first-person party RPG is a thoughtful celebration of old-school exploration, tactical combat and the simple pleasure of getting hopelessly lost underground.
Underkeep invites you to assemble a party of four adventurers before setting out into a dangerous fantasy world filled with forgotten dungeons, strange inhabitants, dangerous creatures and secrets waiting to be uncovered. Its grid-based movement immediately establishes its retro credentials, but the turn-based combat gives the adventure a slightly different personality from many of its inspirations. There is no need to frantically shuffle around enemies or rely on lightning-fast reactions. Instead, battles become deliberate encounters where positioning, abilities and equipment matter far more than reflexes.
What makes the experience particularly appealing is the sense that the developers genuinely understand what made these older adventures special. The handcrafted environments, traditional party building and emphasis on exploration all feel rooted in a genuine affection for the genre. At the same time, Underkeep is not interested in making players suffer through every inconvenience associated with 1990s RPG design. It wants to bring back the adventure, not necessarily the frustration.
Building a Party Worth Remembering
Creating your adventuring party is one of the most enjoyable parts of Underkeep. You bring together four characters from a selection of fantasy races and classes, each offering distinct abilities and opportunities for experimentation. Rather than forcing players into rigid combinations, the game encourages a more flexible approach to character creation. Unusual pairings, such as a Slugman paladin or a Blood Mage built to stand on the frontline, help give the process a personality of its own.
That freedom is important because a party-based RPG should make you feel invested in the characters you take into danger. Choosing four adventurers is not simply about selecting the most powerful combination of statistics. It is about deciding how you want to approach the challenges ahead, which abilities complement one another, and where you might be willing to take a gamble. A balanced group can provide reassurance, but experimenting with less conventional combinations can be equally rewarding when everything begins to work together.
Character development also revolves around equipment, abilities, and the relationships between different parts of your build. Finding a particularly useful weapon or piece of armour can influence how you approach future encounters, while combining spells and abilities allows you to develop a party that feels increasingly capable. There is a satisfying sense of progression as your adventurers become better equipped to deal with the dangers lurking deeper within Underkeep.
However, the equipment system does have some frustrating restrictions. Certain weapons and armour require specific combinations of character attributes, sometimes demanding statistics that might not initially seem particularly relevant to the item’s intended use. This can make an exciting discovery feel disappointing when your favourite character cannot actually equip it. The absence of character respec options makes those decisions more significant, and players who distribute their initial attributes poorly may find themselves locked out of equipment they would otherwise love to use.
Exploration Is Still the Heart of the Adventure
Underkeep understands that dungeon crawling is about more than fighting monsters. Some of the best moments in the genre come from discovering a hidden passage, finding a switch behind an apparently ordinary wall, or realising that a puzzle has been hiding its solution in plain sight. Exploration is therefore a major part of the experience, with handcrafted environments designed to reward players who take their time and investigate their surroundings.
The world extends beyond traditional underground corridors, taking adventurers through forests, open plains, swamps and forgotten ruins. This variety helps prevent the journey from becoming a succession of visually identical dungeons, while strange inhabitants and environmental encounters give the world a little more personality. Quests and discoveries also provide reasons to explore beyond the most obvious route, and some choices can influence what happens next. It is a welcome reminder that the world is not simply a collection of rooms waiting to be cleared.
Grid-based movement is particularly effective at encouraging methodical exploration. Every step feels deliberate, and the limited perspective naturally creates curiosity about what might be waiting beyond the next turn. You are encouraged to pay attention to your surroundings, consider possible routes and remember locations that might become relevant later. It is a style of exploration that might feel old-fashioned to players accustomed to enormous open worlds, but there is a particular pleasure in gradually understanding a carefully constructed environment.
The developers have also made sensible decisions to remove unnecessary friction. An interactive automap allows you to keep track of explored areas, while custom markers can identify locked doors, suspicious locations and puzzles that you have not yet solved. These are small additions, but they make a substantial difference when navigating larger environments. Rather than forcing players to maintain endless handwritten notes just to remember where they have been, Underkeep gives you useful tools without removing the satisfaction of discovering things yourself.
Combat Without the Need for Quick Feet
Perhaps the most interesting design decision is the move towards fully turn-based combat. Traditional grid-based dungeon crawlers often place considerable emphasis on movement during encounters, with players constantly repositioning to avoid attacks and exploit openings. Underkeep takes a different approach, allowing enemies to act when you do. This makes battles more controlled and gives you the opportunity to think through your decisions without worrying about missing a movement input or reacting too slowly.
Combat is built around combining your party’s abilities, managing resources and exploiting enemy weaknesses. Different creatures demand different approaches, and simply relying on the same attack in every encounter is unlikely to be the most effective strategy. Positioning still matters, particularly when deciding which characters should take the brunt of an enemy’s attention and which should remain available to deliver spells or support abilities. The result is a system that feels more like a traditional tactical RPG than an action game disguised as a dungeon crawler.
There is a welcome sense of accessibility here. Players who enjoy the strategic side of classic RPGs but dislike the frantic movement associated with some modern dungeon crawlers should feel particularly comfortable. You can take a moment to consider your options, assess the situation and decide how best to use your party. That slower pace also makes it easier to appreciate the individual abilities of your adventurers rather than simply relying on whichever attack produces the biggest numbers.
The downside is that encounters can become somewhat repetitive once your party develops a reliable set of abilities. As your characters grow stronger, certain damage skills can become dependable solutions to a wide range of encounters. The strategic possibilities remain enjoyable, but the excitement of discovering new combinations can gradually give way to familiar routines. A little more variation in how enemies challenge established strategies would have helped keep the later stages feeling consistently fresh.
Secrets, Traps and the Joy of Discovery
The handcrafted nature of Underkeep is one of its greatest strengths. Rather than relying entirely on randomly assembled environments, the developers have created a world filled with deliberate encounters, hidden switches, secret passages and environmental puzzles. This gives exploration a more personal quality, as though someone has carefully considered what players might discover when they investigate an unusual corner or test an apparent dead end.
Traps and riddles provide welcome changes of pace between battles, although some puzzles can be cryptic. A handful of clues are vague enough to leave players wondering whether they have overlooked something obvious or simply misunderstood the wording. There is a fine line between a satisfying puzzle and an unnecessarily obscure one, and Underkeep occasionally steps over it. Nevertheless, the satisfaction of eventually finding a solution is worth the occasional bout of head-scratching.
The game’s expected 15 to 20-hour adventure also feels like a sensible length for this type of experience. It offers enough time to explore, develop your party and uncover secrets without demanding the kind of enormous commitment associated with some sprawling modern RPGs. There is a clear appeal in knowing that your journey has a manageable scope, particularly when the emphasis is on carefully designed locations rather than endless map markers.
Hand Drawn Charm With a Retro Heart
Visually, Underkeep combines three-dimensional, grid-based environments with hand-drawn character portraits, monster sprites and encounter illustrations. It is a lovely combination that captures some of the charm of older PC RPGs without feeling like an attempt to recreate a game from decades ago. The environments provide a sense of depth, while the two-dimensional artwork gives the creatures and characters a distinctive personality.
The different locations also help establish the atmosphere. Damp crypts, misty forests, forgotten ruins and other fantasy environments provide a varied backdrop for the adventure, and the hand-drawn presentation gives everything a slightly storybook quality. There is a sense of warmth to the art direction that works particularly well alongside the game’s traditional fantasy setting. It is not trying to compete with photorealistic modern RPGs, and it is all the better for having its own visual identity.
The tone also benefits from a little dry humour, preventing the adventure from taking itself too seriously. Fantasy games do not always need to be relentlessly grim to create a convincing world, and the occasional lighter moment gives Underkeep an approachable personality. The soundtrack and environmental audio complete the presentation, using atmospheric dungeon music and distinctive sound cues to support exploration and combat. It is an understated approach, but one that suits the experience rather well.
Controller support is another welcome addition, allowing players to enjoy the adventure from the comfort of a sofa rather than being tied to a desk. Combined with the automap improvements and more forgiving inventory management, it demonstrates an understanding that modernising a classic genre does not have to mean changing everything that made it enjoyable in the first place.
A Classic Formula With Modern Sensibilities
Underkeep is at its best when it lets players lose themselves in exploration, gradually developing their party and uncovering the secrets hidden throughout its handcrafted world. Its flexible character creation gives the adventure personality, while the turn-based combat offers a welcome alternative to more reflex-driven dungeon crawlers. The presentation is charming, the environments reward curiosity, and the quality-of-life improvements make the experience considerably more comfortable than some of its inspirations.
There are still areas that could be improved. Restrictive equipment requirements can make character progression unnecessarily frustrating, while the lack of respec options means early decisions can have consequences that are difficult to correct. Some puzzles are also more obscure than they need to be, and combat occasionally settles into familiar routines once the party becomes established. These issues prevent the experience from reaching quite the same heights as the very best modern examples of the genre.
Even so, Rake in Grass has delivered something that feels genuinely affectionate rather than merely nostalgic. Underkeep understands that the appeal of classic dungeon crawlers was never just about pixel art, grid movement or fighting monsters. It was about the excitement of discovering an unfamiliar world, the satisfaction of building a capable party and the feeling that every corridor might contain something worth finding.
Verdict
Underkeep is a thoroughly enjoyable tribute to the golden age of dungeon crawling, combining traditional grid-based exploration with thoughtful turn-based combat and a wonderfully charming visual style. Its flexible party creation encourages experimentation, while the handcrafted environments and environmental secrets provide plenty of reasons to keep exploring. The modern conveniences are particularly well judged, removing much of the tedious inventory management and navigation without sacrificing the satisfaction of old-school adventuring.
Restrictive equipment requirements, occasional cryptic puzzles and some repetitive late-game encounters hold it back slightly, but they do little to diminish the overall experience. Rake in Grass has created a fantasy adventure that understands its inspirations while giving the genre a more comfortable modern identity. For anyone who remembers spending hours exploring the dungeons of the 1990s, or simply wants a thoughtful party RPG that puts exploration and discovery first, Underkeep is an adventure well worth taking.


















